How did we pick these five?
We started from the joints that show up repeatedly in credible Texas barbecue coverage, then cut anything we could not confirm is currently open and operating on the schedule it advertises. From there the ranking is about the brisket, because brisket is how Texas barbecue is judged and it is the hardest thing on the menu to fake.
We weighted consistency heavily. A place that is spectacular on the day a reviewer visits and merely fine the following Tuesday is not a recommendation, it is a coin flip. Every joint here has a track record long enough to be a pattern rather than a lucky visit.
We did not rank on line length. A long line means a place is popular, not that it is good, and some of the best barbecue in Dallas is served at lunch counters with no wait at all.
What should you know before you drive?
Barbecue is the one restaurant category where showing up at the wrong hour means going home hungry. A few things worth internalizing:
| Joint | Best time to arrive | Risk of selling out |
| Cattleack | Right at opening, on an open day | High. This is the point of the place. |
| Pecan Lodge | Opening, or the last hour | Moderate on beef ribs |
| Terry Black's | Anytime | Low |
| Slow Bone | Early lunch | Moderate on fried chicken Wednesdays |
| Hurtado | Anytime except a game day | Low |
Call or check the site before you go. Barbecue hours change more than any other category we cover. Cattleack in particular runs a limited schedule that shifts, and a wasted drive to Farmers Branch is a bad afternoon.
Order by weight, not by plate. A half pound of brisket per adult is a reasonable starting point if you are also getting ribs or sausage. A full pound is a commitment.
Moist over lean, almost always. If you are new to this, ask for moist brisket. Lean is for people who have already decided they prefer it.
What about Fort Worth and Lockhart?
Fair question, and the honest answer is that some of the best barbecue in North Texas is not in Dallas. Goldee's in Fort Worth has ranked at the very top of Texas Monthly's statewide list, and it is roughly a forty-minute drive from downtown Dallas on a good day.
Lockhart, three hours south, was named the Barbecue Capital of Texas by the state legislature and has several legendary pits inside a few square blocks. If you are building a trip around barbecue rather than fitting barbecue into a trip, that is where to point the car.
But if you are in Dallas this week and want to eat well, the five above will do it.
What should you do next?
Pick based on your schedule rather than the ranking. If you have a free Thursday or Friday morning, go to Cattleack, because that is the one you cannot do on a whim. If you have a Saturday afternoon and a group, go to Pecan Lodge or Terry Black's in Deep Ellum and make a day of the neighborhood. If you have a Wednesday lunch hour, Slow Bone.
Hungry for more of the state? We are working through the best barbecue across Texas city by city, and there is plenty more worth eating in Dallas.